Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
Follow our Twitter feedHeavy Rain preview is in the house(!)
SIGN IN/JOIN UP
GamesForumsCheatsVideo
Final Fantasy CC: Crystal Bearers release date | Nintendo downloads: Pokémon, Uno | Zelda mystery: internet speculation 1 truth 0 | PES 2010 download content dated | History of Nintendo: The Game Boy Color | Pokémon double release tomorrow | Sky Crawlers: Feb take-off | Miyamoto: "New SMB Wii the most challenging yet" | Phoenix Wright Wii Ware: screenshots and date | Aonuma hopeful for Zelda E3 "surprises" | PES 2010 Wii gets launch DLC | Nintendo reaffirms Wii Vitality Sensor date | Activision cracks EA with Sledgehammer | Phoenix Wright heading to Wii | No More Heroes for Xbox 360, PS3 | Assassin's Creed II DS review is in | New Super Mario Bros launch trailer | Square and Eidos confirm first proper collaboration | Ubisoft deny Rabbids recall rumour | Metroid Prime: "it's not over" | Sgt Pepper's out for Beatles: Rock Band | Nintendo: HD Wii isn't "the next step" | New Super Mario: No online play 'developers' decision' | Zelda: Spirit Tracks review: "A wonderful game" | Gearbox rejected Blade Runner game
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Download PC Games
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » Nintendo » News
PreviousShameless Wii rip-off hits China 91 NiGHTS screens in your face  Next

First Mario Galaxy review faked

"No one in the world" has played final code, says Nintendo
A review of Super Mario Galaxy that cropped up in Belgian magazine 'Gunk' is far from what it seems and was not done using a final copy of the game, Nintendo has told CVG.

They gave Mario's next quest 92 percent in what would have been the world exclusive review, which spans just a single page and isn't even shouted about on the cover.

Why such a short review for the most anticipated Wii game yet? Probably because they've only played the short E3 demo, like the rest of us.

"It is 100 percent not a review", a Nintendo spokesman told us, who went on to confirm that "no one in the world will have access to final game code until October 10 at the earliest."

computerandvideogames.com
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
Read all 15 commentsPost a Comment
Sarcasme-mode aan... Gunk op zijn best, goed bezig. Sarcasme-mode uit.... (That's Dutch, so they understand me...)
AlienStorm on 1 Oct '07
Laughing The things some people do to get a world exclusive. Now if only mario Galaxy would arrive in time for my birthday Sad
vectra on 1 Oct '07
Don't know about anyone else but I don't own a Wii (intend to get one next year) and my most anticipated game is Super Smash Bros Brawl. I couldn't care less about Mario Galaxies... Laughing
vulcanraven01 on 1 Oct '07
100 percent not a review... is that some subtle suggestion that Mario Galaxy will be a 100% game... I hope so.. 100% would make it better than Mario 64... I cant wait. Anyway.. just hurry up and release it in the UK already!
dannybuoy on 1 Oct '07
So I'm guessing it was a page 7/8ths full of pictures, with a paragraph which roughly translates as:

"Mario Galaxy looks well good, he looks like in his last games but better-like and with space and stuff. All in all, our in-depth review of the whole game gives him 92% (deducted 8% for having a gay bee suit)"

That's what I would expect from a magazine called gunk...the nuts/zoo of Belgium, right?
chris_gower on 1 Oct '07
Gunk's editor reacted on their forums: http://forum.gunk.be/showpost.php?p=791697&postcount=12(in Dutch).

They were allowed to play Super Mario Galaxy for 2 days on a Nintendo event here in Belgium. Based on that play session, they 'reviewed' the game. They have e-mail confirmation from their Nintendo rep to publish the review.

Some background information: Gunk magazine was founded by Frank Molnar (http://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Molnar), who participated in the Belgian Big Brother and has since been the host of several game programmes, focussed mainly on parties and babes instead of previews/reviews (See for yourself).
evil_g on 1 Oct '07
Hey,

I am the chief editor of GUNKmagazine and I have an official mail from a Belgian Nintendo spokesperson which states that we had the autorisation to REVIEW the game.

So anyone who has doubts can email me and I can send him or her the mail which states the above.

Kindly yours,

Christophe
Praga on 1 Oct '07
Hey,

I am the chief editor of GUNKmagazine and I have an official mail from a Belgian Nintendo spokesperson which states that we had the autorisation to REVIEW the game.

So anyone who has doubts can email me and I can send him or her the mail which states the above.

Kindly yours,

Christophe

OH MY GOD! /points
IT'S A GAY!!!!
gothchild on 1 Oct '07
Hey,

I am the chief editor of GUNKmagazine and I have an official mail from a Belgian Nintendo spokesperson which states that we had the autorisation to REVIEW the game.

So anyone who has doubts can email me and I can send him or her the mail which states the above.

Kindly yours,

Christophe

You might have a letter with the authority to review the game ( I going to try this ) but without a review copy they are saying it's not review,

I think you will get a review copy ( defo going to try this ) from them, never thought I would write the word review so much about a review that's not a review.
Gaz Vonhammer on 1 Oct '07
Hey,

I am the chief editor of GUNKmagazine and I have an official mail from a Belgian Nintendo spokesperson which states that we had the autorisation to REVIEW the game.

So anyone who has doubts can email me and I can send him or her the mail which states the above.

Kindly yours,

Christophe

You might have a letter with the authority to review the game ( I going to try this ) but without a review copy they are saying it's not review,

I think you will get a review copy ( defo going to try this ) from them, never thought I would write the word review so much about a review that's not a review.

I thought My response was more subtle and efficient myself..
gothchild on 1 Oct '07
This Gunk Magazine sounds like a pile of s**t if you ask me and I hope it has lost all credibility with its readers.
seancuk23 on 1 Oct '07
I'm from Belgium & Gunk is a LOT of crap (all the other Belgian games mags are also.). The television show is even much much worse. I'm glad most of you don't understan dutch; so you wouldn't have to read it.
As a games fan; I hate the way they always talk about boobs instead of games. It's a mag for kids under 10.
Frank Molnar is gay. So is Christophe & the rest.

I'm glad there are british mags. They are the best.

Kick ass gaming, my ass.
PU for president.
janijuana on 1 Oct '07
I'm from Belgium & Gunk is a LOT of crap (all the other Belgian games mags are also.). The television show is even much much worse. I'm glad most of you don't understan dutch; so you wouldn't have to read it.
As a games fan; I hate the way they always talk about boobs instead of games. It's a mag for kids under 10.
Frank Molnar is gay. So is Christophe & the rest.

I'm glad there are british mags. They are the best.

Kick ass gaming, my ass.
PU for president.

Damn Straight! Cool
seancuk23 on 2 Oct '07
Hey,

I am the chief editor of GUNKmagazine and I have an official mail from a Belgian Nintendo spokesperson which states that we had the autorisation to REVIEW the game.

So anyone who has doubts can email me and I can send him or her the mail which states the above.

Kindly yours,

Christophe

OMFG, you stole my exclusive, Nintendo of Europe promised me the first review since I am lead writer of my magazine and I am the song of Iwata, curse you Belgian currs
TomSmithUK on 2 Oct '07
This Email that authorizes gank to review the game... surely they meant a review copy not a demo ive seen on game trailers or everywebsite in the world....

I could probably get permission off Ninty to review Galaxies as long as i used my own copy of the game (as Digitiser sometimes used to)or was sent a review copy....

Rolling Eyes
sevvy b goode on 2 Oct '07
Read all 15 commentsPost a Comment
// Related Content
Reviews:
Previews:
News:
More Related
// The Best ofCVG
Click here to subscribe to OXM magazine.
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Super Smash Bros. Brawl | The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess | Call Of Duty Modern Warfare: Reflex | The Beatles: Rock Band | FIFA 10 | Metroid Other M
New Super Mario Bros. Wii | Guitar Hero 5 | Red Steel 2 | A Boy and his Blob | Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Winter Games
Top Reviews: PES 2010 | New Super Mario Bros. Wii | Rabbids Go Home | A Boy and his Blob | Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Winter Games | Spore Hero
Spyborgs | Dead Space Extraction | Metroid Prime Trilogy | Wii Sports Resort | The Conduit
Copyright 2006 - 2009 Future Publishing Limited,
Beauford Court, 30 Monmouth Street, Bath, UK BA1 2BW
England and Wales company registration number 2008885