Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
Follow our Twitter feedBioShock 2 review coming 5pm GMT! http://bit.ly/93OAMH
SIGN IN/JOIN UP
GamesForumsCheatsStore
Diablo III Monk revealed | Google launches Facebook rival | No Dead Space 2 on PC | Ghost Recon: Future Soldier trailer out | Lego Universe beta sign-up open | Assassin's Creed goes to Rome | Mod of the Year Awards announced | FIFA fans break Guinness World Record | All EA titles "will have an online component" | BioShock 2 review round-up | BioShock 2 is "only pure shooter out right now" | Deus Ex: Human Revolution trademarked | Exclusive BioShock 2 multiplayer video | Dragon Age goes triple platinum | Mass Effect 2 DLC coming tomorrow | Dead Space 2 early 2011 | EA announces Q3 loss | Square Enix reports profits up 68% | Aliens vs Predator demo hits 14k downloads on Live | New Vegas 'wittier' than Fallout 3 | Just Cause 2 trailer lands | Bioware details Star Wars: The Old Republic Sith classes | Lego Star Wars: The Clone Wars announced | Metro 2033 trailer number three arrives | UK CHART: Mass Effect 2 keeps top spot
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Download PC Games
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » PC » Reviews
PreviousArmed Assault: Queen's Gambit PCCall of Duty 4: Modern Warfare PCNext

The Witcher Review

A grey-haired mercenary, shunned by society, but enough about Richie Shoemaker...
Fantasy games come in many shapes and sizes, but most of them strictly follow the code of featuring the great, the good and the virtuous fending off the bad, the corrupted and the green-skinned.

Sex is generally confined to a pretty elf wearing a chain mail bra, and political comment never strays much further than a Greenpeace quest in which raw magic has infected some wandering hedgehog creatures and not only rendered them mad, but also significantly upped their armour stats.

The Witcher, then, enters our midst as somewhat of a game of our times. The authorities in and around the plague-ridden city of Vizima perpetuate a culture of fear and suspicion - freedom fighters could just as easily be called terrorists and racial segregation is rife.

Moral values aren't so much blurred as smudged about the place by a recently-licked thumb - even those who might openly oppose the oppressors are seeking some kind of capitol gain, the undead have a conscience, drug use is a major issue and individuals will use whatever means necessary to get their way - by telling porkies, by betrayal, or by allowing you pump them for information. And by that I mean with sex.

Characters doing the nasty are often hidden behind layered and blurred sequences, and you don't get to see much drug abuse (thankfully, since it appears the offending material must be applied to one's bell end) but with mention of rape, suicide and revenge, the world of The Witcher makes Azeroth et al look like Balamory.

The story focuses on you, Witcher 'White Wolf' Geralt, one of a roving band of mercenary monster hunters. The crumbling fortress of their once revered clan has been attacked and the secrets behind your mutation abilities are stolen.

It's your job to find a way to recover the secrets before they are put to nefarious use, all whilst finding out about your past and that of your dwindling clan. It's perhaps not the most exciting premise, but the presentation and pacing of the story is excellent throughout, from the lengthy opening cinematic even to the hand-drawn screens that guard the transitions as new areas load into memory.

Most noteworthy are the cutscenes, which have been storyboarded and edited with real cinematic flair and, together with the voiceovers and script, make The Witcher one of the best examples of interactive fiction I've enjoyed.

Those who like to spend hours rolling characters and selecting facial furniture might be upset to hear that you get what you're given. Geralt is square-jawed, with cat-like eyes, white hair and a face that's endured more stitches than a Bangladeshi T‑shirt factory.

You can't even change his name. Customisation comes later, with experience points turned into coin, that can be spent on new and upgraded skills. There are no character classes to speak of.

The Witcher is a master swordsman, with disciplines that vary from heavy-hitting armour twattage (our term), to fast attack and dealing with groups. You spend your bronze, silver and gold experience coins on specialising in these, either using your normal Witcher's sword, or your silver one.

As you learn (or, rather, relearn, since you seem to be forever recovering from amnesia), spells in the form of 'signs' become available, which can be upgraded in the same way as your fighting and attribute skills. And as you find and read books and scrolls, your in-game info repository allows you new abilities and to take on new missions.

The game's structure is a series of chapters, with some quests spanning and evolving across a number of acts, and of course a fair number of side-quests that require you to go somewhere and slice up a specified number of monsters and bring back evidence of the massacre to secure a reward.

In this area, perhaps there is little that is startlingly original, but that doesn't detract from the essential fun of visiting new areas, slaying new monsters or meeting new characters.

Yes it can get repetitive going from one area of the city to another to complete a mission, but then so was Grand Theft Auto, and so was Oblivion, and as with these games the world of The Witcher is one you always feel a part of and that alone compels you to explore every corner.

Much has been made of the game's combat system, which allows you to chain together attacks, so long as you time your mouse-clicks correctly. In fact, at higher experience levels you can link together enough leaps and devastating blows to secure an honorary degree from the Jedi Academy.

In practise, whilst the combat isn't quite as dumb as your usual action-based RPG, it's no Street Fighter II. But the combat is an enjoyable diversion from the main course of weaving your way through 40-plus hours of cracking storyline.

If I had to gripe about anything it would be that in open areas the illusion of freedom is diminished somewhat by impassable fences that in reality would splinter on a windy day. There is far too much repetition of character avatars as well, with some NPCs looking identical, even in the same areas of the game. Other problems are more ones of personal taste.

I found the supposedly tactical zoomed out view to be overly-cumbersome considering you control only one character - the over-the-shoulder view is just so much more immersive. And finally, the world of The Witcher is primarily a man's one, and whilst there are female characters with strong roles, they are primarily there to be conquered sex-wise or otherwise.

To be fair though, it's something of a novelty to have room available in a list of negatives to be able to castigate a game's misogynist overtones - because in every other department The Witcher is an intelligent, adult and thoroughly compelling adventure.

PC Zone Magazine
// Overview
Verdict
Compelling and unique
Uppers
  Beautifully realised world
  Strong characters, epic story
  Unique character development options
  Decisions can bite you in the ass
Downers
  Combat is visual rather than tactical
  A mite sexist
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
Read all 12 commentsPost a Comment
This message is not being displayed because the poster is banned.
humorguy on 7 Nov '07
Tosh like this?

Have you actually played the game?


If you had a look around the net you'll find alot of people have been pleasently suprised by this game including myself.

You also critise COD:4 for only being 5 hours long, yet this game has hours of gameplay and you write it off?

I would have been more worried about PC Zone if this game got a low score as it's probably the best RPG i've played since KOTOR.

I've also only come across a couple of reviews which gave this game a 7, and only 1 big site which also gave Mafia 4/10. go figure.
Frosti on 7 Nov '07
I don't really think that you can judge a game on gameplay time alone. Sure, CoD4 might be short, but the multiplayer is really what most people will buy the game for. After all, I never actually played the single player part of CoD & CoD2 until many months after buying the game...I just wasn't interested.

The original CoD was worth it for the multiplay alone, I must have spent hundreds of hours online playing it.
Aircool_212 on 8 Nov '07
I've been playing this game and it is not tosh, I've really been enjoying it. Still haven't finished it yet, I'm on chapter four at the moment.

And I know plenty of others who enjoy it too.

I'm not wondering why they gave it 8.8, at all. Seems about right to me.

And when I've finished it, I'll go through it again to see what consequences the other choices will reveal.
freds1 on 8 Nov '07
@ humorguy:- how the F**k did u get that this game is tosh????!!!!

it is an amazing feat imo, and would have given it a 9 as i think it beats oblivion in many ways, except the combat.

cod 4 is probably an amazing game also thats 5 hours but remember - its quality not quantity u dope!

ud be complaining if the game was really long and s**te!!!

p.s. learn how to speak english cus i dont think any1 can understand what you say.
voodoo172 on 8 Nov '07
Humourguy, you're an idiot - quite clearly you haven't played the game and simply want to rant about COD4.

This game is fantastic, reminds me of Planescape Torment in setting and any game that does that deserves a score above 8.5 Wink
Chimpster on 8 Nov '07
If someone has a personal vendetta against PC ZONE, yet still posts on the forums and digs PCZ at every chance he gets, I would say such a person is an absolutely t**tty s**t.
SaBrE_UK on 10 Nov '07
This message is not being displayed because the poster is banned.
humorguy on 11 Nov '07
You haven't responded at all to my points?

Why is this game tosh?

As i said earlier this is one of the best games to have come out on the pc which

1. isn't a FPS
2. Is a hell of a lot longer than 5 hours
3. Is exclusively for the PC

If you expect people to take your comments seriously then you have to back up what you say.

Unless of course your just here to rant. Rolling Eyes
Frosti on 11 Nov '07
Yeah, he's just trying to sound intelligent bless him without actually making any relevant points.

To be quite frank humourguy, I really don't care about COD4 - ain't my cup of tea. However, this game is so far removed from "tosh" that it leads me to believe that you're a jumped up, arrogant numpty who clearly wants to make a point reguardless of it's relevance to the issue at hand (being the Witcher review).
I doubt you've played the game, I doubt you ever will and I doubt you're even aware that this game lasts in excess of 30-50 hours.

When you're ready to talk about WHY this game doesn't deserve a decent score maybe we can have something sensible to talk about. In the meantime, I'm going to go back to enjoying one of the finest RPG masterpieces the PC has seen since KOTOR and Planescape Torment, the last decent adult RPG.
Aside from some technical issues (which I'm confident they'll solve, they're already working on loading time issues), this game is a real classic RPG. After Oblivion I was worried that RPG's were going to go down the road of having pretty graphics, lots of action but no real substance. Thankfully, this game has reinstated my faith in the genre, here's hoping it's not another 5-10 years before another one comes along!
Chimpster on 11 Nov '07
This message is not being displayed because the poster is banned.
humorguy on 25 Jan '08
Lets just remind ourselves how many times in Oblivion we walked into a shop to see a person locked in the same conversation about mudcrabs we hear in every shop, and then see that this person is talking to themselves about how good the shop run by themself is.

Lets also remind ourselves that in medieval times every town, city, dock, shed, wood, grove and church was rife with whores.

You have the choice to play over the shoulder or as you put it "Like Neverwinter Nights 2"
Meaning you can play however the s**t you want.
If you've played beyond 10 minutes, you'd see that if this game was first person the fighting system would be so abysmal it would be criminal.
Not that I'm saying the fighting system is gods gift to men.

Its an awesome story as far as I can see, and if they made it like the ever-so-bland Oblivion I wouldn't have bought it.
Arko on 11 Oct '08
Read all 12 commentsPost a Comment
// Screenshots
PreviousNext4 / 4 Screenshots
// Related Content
Reviews:
Previews:
Interviews:
News:
More Related
// The Best ofCVG
Click here to subscribe to Official Nintendo magazine.
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Unreal Tournament III | Football Manager 2007 | Medieval 2: Total War | Age of Conan: Rise of the Godslayer | FIFA Online | Alien vs. Predator
Dragon Age: Origins Awakening | Final Fantasy XIV Online | Games of the Decade | Battlefield: Bad Company 2 | Mass Effect 2
Top Reviews: BioShock 2 | Mass Effect 2 | Left 4 Dead 2 | Tropico 3 | Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 | Dragon Age: Origins
Football Manager 2010 | Championship Manager 2010 | Borderlands | Risen | Operation Flashpoint: Dragon Rising
Copyright 2006 - 2009 Future Publishing Limited,
Beauford Court, 30 Monmouth Street, Bath, UK BA1 2BW
England and Wales company registration number 2008885