Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
Follow our Twitter feedQ: Are footy shirts appropriate office wear? A: As long as they?re claret and blue? http://bit.ly/9QuAIV
SIGN IN/JOIN UP
GamesForumsCheatsStore
Nintendo 'special' reveal on Feb 24 | MLB 2K10 gameplay trailer arrives | Ace Attorney Investigations demo out | All EA titles "will have an online component" | Pirate ordered to pay Nintendo $1.5 million | NBA Jam Wii screenshots | EA announces Q3 loss | Square Enix reports profits up 68% | All Star Karate unveiled | Greg Hastings Paintball 2 coming soon | Lego Star Wars: The Clone Wars announced | Miyamoto working on new MotionPlus game | UK CHART: Mass Effect 2 keeps top spot | FIFA 11 won't drop the ball - EA | NGamer: Sonic playable in Mario Galaxy 2 | Phoenix Wright (WiiWare) screens | Ubisoft: "Big announcement" next week | Art: EA's Road Rash, Oliver Twist(!) | A first-person shooter... for Facebook | Sonic the Hedgehog 4 trailer in HD | Pics: iPad game view modes | Capcom: We're ready to make 3D games | The Grinder no longer Wii exclusive | Iron Man 2 trailer out | Sonic & Knuckles on Virtual Console next week
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Download PC Games
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » Nintendo » News
PreviousNintendo confirms first-half releases Wii makes doctors better surgeons?  Next

Wii lightsaber set to disappoint?

No 1:1 movement and force power malarkey set for Wii version of Force Unleashed - just give us our Wii lightsabre!
New details have come in on the (slightly) anticipated Wii version of The Force Unleashed, which finally brings saber-swinging Jedi antics to Nintendo's console. Unfortunately though, it's sounding like a far cry from the 1:1 saber swinging we were hoping for.

According to the latest Game Informer, The Force Unleashed will not use the Wii Remote for 1:1 lightsaber swinging, but instead your Force Powers will be motion controlled.

By this we mean that your movements with the Wii Remote won't be copied perfectly in screen, not that you can't use it to control the lightsabre.

Force Push, for example, is pulled off by (you guessed it) "pushing" the remote towards the screen.

It's Marvel: Ultimate Alliance with Storm Troopers then. Not that we weren't expecting that.

We've still got our fingers crossed that Lucasarts will give us the beautiful Wii Lightsaber action we've been demanding since Wii's announcement, but at the moment we can only prepare for disappointment.

Guess we'll have to play out our Star Wars fantasies with the toy swords for the time being then...

computerandvideogames.com
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
Read all 28 commentsPost a Comment
That is disappointing, maybe they are finding 1:1 wiisabre swinging to hard to implement with all the other moves and actions the player will have to control so decided to ditch it?
pR!M8 on 17 Jan '08
Well, that solves one issue for me. Do I go for the pretty 360 version, or the cool Wii version. Now the Wii version isn't gonna be as cool as we'd hoped, it's no longer a dilemma...
_Marty_ on 17 Jan '08
And this was the reason that I realised that the Wii was 99% hype.

Yes, it's an intuitive control and all that b******s, but at the end of the day, flicking right twice performs a set move. What the hell is the point in that? You might as well just use a controller and tap A twice.

I bought a Wii on launch and Red Steel was such a massive let down - it would seem if it IS possible to implement 1:1 control, it won't happen for a long time yet.
chris_gower on 17 Jan '08
Just buy a Force FX lightsaber from Master Replicas before they run out (they've just lost the licence to Bandai, makers of go-bots and other plastic tat). Seriously cool. Try searching for Sheffield and lightsaber on YouTube to see some friends of mine having fun with theirs (completely smut-free!).
Tao on 17 Jan '08
i thought Wii owners would be used to disappointment by now.... Wink
hollywood111 on 17 Jan '08
They are very stupid or very very lazy, if it does not have motion controlled lightsaber action, I won't be getting this game at all! Mad
seancuk23 on 17 Jan '08
Just like I said the other day, Lucasarts are generally crap. I'm not remotely (ha ha!) surprised by this. And frankly, I don't care either
JuiKuen on 17 Jan '08
Lucasarts did a preview of this game at the Star Wars celebration last year. It was to a packed audience.

But did they release ONE single piece of new information, or a single new screenshot?

Nope. It was a complete waste of 90 minutes of my life and was nothing more than a publicity stunt...

Total balls
Karis on 17 Jan '08
Once again Nintendo will have to be relied upon to deliver the goods.

Bring on Wii Zelda.
Biggwedge on 17 Jan '08
absolute BS.

I can move my bat in Wii Sports to be 1:1, and the damn game's been out for over a year now.

Lazy developers. Lucas can suck it hard. He should have demanded 1:1 movement from the dev team.
distant2nd on 17 Jan '08
Pathetic.
Mogs on 17 Jan '08
Grrr Evil or Very Mad

Cue LucasArts CEO complaining that their games arent selling on the wii

Pull your fingers out and work on it! Seriously how hard can it be!!
frichie79 on 17 Jan '08
So I guess I can save my money then and not bother buying the game for my kids? We've got the lego star wars game, and wii light sword attachments (which are very heavy) and most times the kids don't bother with them as you can't wave them about like 'a real lightsaber' whilst playing. Thought this new release would be different grrr
boingboing on 17 Jan '08
What? This is pathetic!

Why on earth not? How about stepping slightly outside the lines and trying something different from the usual third person slasher drawl.

Just try it!

Or, let's take baby steps. How about Wii exclusive 1:1 control sections (a la MOH with the Zapper.)

Or, even a first person on/off rails game with full lightsaber swinging goodness!

Anything to get me waving around like an idiot!
Please!
RumbleThunder on 17 Jan '08
Some of you guys are so overreacting, I mean can any of you actually wield a lightsaber? How exactly do you intend on jumping around, and doing crazy star-wars-esque moves if you are using 1:1 movements? You need a darn site more influence over the control of your character than say, Red steel. But 1:1 movement would fail, badly.
Malmo on 17 Jan '08
Some of you guys are so overreacting, I mean can any of you actually wield a lightsaber? How exactly do you intend on jumping around, and doing crazy star-wars-esque moves if you are using 1:1 movements? You need a darn site more influence over the control of your character than say, Red steel. But 1:1 movement would fail, badly.

.. can we weild lightsabres?

christ man, thats a stupid question.

Video games are meant to let you do this kinda stuff.
I reckon 1:1 could work. You'd need a damn good dev, but I reckon it could work.
If only like ina fight gaming style 'locked into your opponant', first person perspective style.
gothchild on 17 Jan '08
Some of you guys are so overreacting, I mean can any of you actually wield a lightsaber? How exactly do you intend on jumping around, and doing crazy star-wars-esque moves if you are using 1:1 movements? You need a darn site more influence over the control of your character than say, Red steel. But 1:1 movement would fail, badly.

.. can we weild lightsabres?

christ man, thats a stupid question.

Video games are meant to let you do this kinda stuff.
I reckon 1:1 could work. You'd need a damn good dev, but I reckon it could work.
If only like ina fight gaming style 'locked into your opponant', first person perspective style.

How can 1:1 work unless you can actually wield a sword properly. You can't do triple somersaults like yoda can you? Without some preset mechanics it's just going to be you standing around flinging a wii remote, while watching you character boringly do the same thing. I'm not saying make all the mechanics preset, in that moving the wii remote in anyway possible results in one thing happening (much like Red steel), just that there needs to be a balance between the two. And as aforementioned I believe people are overreacting, just because it is not strictly 1:1 doesn't mean they've got a few preselect actions and that is all.

I agree with you with the whole 1:1 first person perspective, but that will become boring incredibly fast if there are no preset moves to actually make the game exciting.
Malmo on 17 Jan '08
Some of you guys are so overreacting, I mean can any of you actually wield a lightsaber? How exactly do you intend on jumping around, and doing crazy star-wars-esque moves if you are using 1:1 movements? You need a darn site more influence over the control of your character than say, Red steel. But 1:1 movement would fail, badly.

.. can we weild lightsabres?

christ man, thats a stupid question.

Video games are meant to let you do this kinda stuff.
I reckon 1:1 could work. You'd need a damn good dev, but I reckon it could work.
If only like ina fight gaming style 'locked into your opponant', first person perspective style.

Crap grammar, brilliant idea.
myoldfruity on 17 Jan '08
Some of you guys are so overreacting, I mean can any of you actually wield a lightsaber? How exactly do you intend on jumping around, and doing crazy star-wars-esque moves if you are using 1:1 movements? You need a darn site more influence over the control of your character than say, Red steel. But 1:1 movement would fail, badly.

.. can we weild lightsabres?

christ man, thats a stupid question.

Video games are meant to let you do this kinda stuff.
I reckon 1:1 could work. You'd need a damn good dev, but I reckon it could work.
If only like ina fight gaming style 'locked into your opponant', first person perspective style.

Crap grammar, brilliant idea.

Hmm, wasn't my most eloquent reply, was it?

Ah well, the point was made.


Malmo:

I see you're point, but I don't really think it would be boring, so long as the developer makes a game not just a tech demo.

For example, I find the 1:1 control on Wii baseball very satisfying; it's great to see such accurate emulation of my wind up.
I don't think you're going to need to have these massive flips you speak of. I'm basically proposed Jedi Knight II with Wii controls.
gothchild on 17 Jan '08


Hmm, wasn't my most eloquent reply, was it?

Ah well, the point was made.


Malmo:

I see you're point, but I don't really think it would be boring, so long as the developer makes a game not just a tech demo.

For example, I find the 1:1 control on Wii baseball very satisfying; it's great to see such accurate emulation of my wind up.
I don't think you're going to need to have these massive flips you speak of. I'm basically proposed Jedi Knight II with Wii controls.

I see your point too, I guess we are just looking at it from two different perspectives. I'm thinking lightsaber duels have to have something a bit more epic than stand there and flick a saber from left to right. it's the kind of thing where you really want to 'get into it', and do some mad 360 degree spins, but sadly playing a game and not looking at the screen don't go well, thus the need for some preset game mechanics.

But don't get me wrong, I wasn't claiming to know the ideals of the control system, just pointing out the overreactions on some people's parts, simply based upon controls which they don't actually know the mechanics of, and instead just think it doesn't follow strict 1:1 motions, therefore it will be crap =/
Malmo on 17 Jan '08


Hmm, wasn't my most eloquent reply, was it?

Ah well, the point was made.


Malmo:

I see you're point, but I don't really think it would be boring, so long as the developer makes a game not just a tech demo.

For example, I find the 1:1 control on Wii baseball very satisfying; it's great to see such accurate emulation of my wind up.
I don't think you're going to need to have these massive flips you speak of. I'm basically proposed Jedi Knight II with Wii controls.

I see your point too, I guess we are just looking at it from two different perspectives. I'm thinking lightsaber duels have to have something a bit more epic than stand there and flick a saber from left to right. it's the kind of thing where you really want to 'get into it', and do some mad 360 degree spins, but sadly playing a game and not looking at the screen don't go well, thus the need for some preset game mechanics.

But don't get me wrong, I wasn't claiming to know the ideals of the control system, just pointing out the overreactions on some people's parts, simply based upon controls which they don't actually know the mechanics of, and instead just think it doesn't follow strict 1:1 motions, therefore it will be crap =/

That attitude just stems from the disappointment.

Take, for example, No More Heroes.
I'm sure it'll be a great game, but am not particularly bothered because of the massive disappointment of learning that attacks will be performed by "pressing A."

Why have a Wii mote if all you do is "press A"?


I see what you mean about the epic and fluidity of the fights, but on the other hand, whilst conventional controllers grant you more freedom of movement, I find, again, "pressing A" or maybe "A+B combo" unsatisfying.

It's like "Whey, I pressed a button and the guy on the screen did a pre-set action!" I'd rather mix things up with my own motions.
gothchild on 17 Jan '08
The reality is that, implementation difficulties aside, the Wii's sensor package is simply not sensitive enough to give you 1:1 correlation.
NegativeZero on 17 Jan '08
I thought they were going to have a separate "Dueling" mode, with the lightsaber stuff? btw, they Wii sensor package is so good it can get 11:1 movement, it's intuitive.
thief on 18 Jan '08
The reality is that, implementation difficulties aside, the Wii's sensor package is simply not sensitive enough to give you 1:1 correlation.

It absolutely is. Go and play baseball on Wii Sports. Stand there and move the bat around - every movement you make is translated on screen. If a frickin' baseball game can do it, some form of sword based (ideally lightsaber) game can too. And who cares if we're not all jedi capable of weilding such weapons, let us worry about that.

I will say I'd be relatively happy if 'boss' fights (jedi duels) were 1:1 controls and the rest of the game was merely preset movements. At least that's something.
_Marty_ on 18 Jan '08
The reality is that, implementation difficulties aside, the Wii's sensor package is simply not sensitive enough to give you 1:1 correlation.

It absolutely is. Go and play baseball on Wii Sports. Stand there and move the bat around - every movement you make is translated on screen. If a frickin' baseball game can do it, some form of sword based (ideally lightsaber) game can too. And who cares if we're not all jedi capable of weilding such weapons, let us worry about that.

I will say I'd be relatively happy if 'boss' fights (jedi duels) were 1:1 controls and the rest of the game was merely preset movements. At least that's something.

I was just going to suggest that!! Obviously it could get quite tedious fighting your way through levels weilding a lightsabre especially if it takes more than a couple of hits to take down a henchman, but if you could get to a boss fight each level and after a nifty cut seen of you squaring up, then go into 1st person for an all out light sabre fight, that would be cool. Maybe you wouldnt be able to do spins and somersaults but i would be happy pressing a button to launch in to the air and then bringing down the remote in a chop to do a jedi attack!
frichie79 on 18 Jan '08
Tell you what, if the force powers work like this I'll be pretty damn happy with that.
_Marty_ on 18 Jan '08
Agreed....

WHY THE FU(K NOT!!!
frichie79 on 18 Jan '08
i dont understand why the controls will be so crap!!
cuz if u have wiisports play it and the baseball bat is so well done! u move the remote and it follows very well so y cant star wars do that!! Evil or Very Mad eithier theyer dumb or lazy
glitchboi on 22 Jun '08
Read all 28 commentsPost a Comment
// Related Content
News:
More Related
// The Best ofCVG
Get FREE games at FileRadar.
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Super Smash Bros. Brawl | The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess | The Last Story | Sonic & Sega All-Stars Racing | Call Of Duty Modern Warfare: Reflex | The Beatles: Rock Band
FIFA 10 | Metroid Other M | New Super Mario Bros. Wii | Guitar Hero 5 | Red Steel 2
Top Reviews: Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles: The Crystal Bearers | Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles | PES 2010 | New Super Mario Bros. Wii | Rabbids Go Home | A Boy and his Blob
Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Winter Games | Spore Hero | Spyborgs | Dead Space Extraction | Metroid Prime Trilogy
Copyright 2006 - 2009 Future Publishing Limited,
Beauford Court, 30 Monmouth Street, Bath, UK BA1 2BW
England and Wales company registration number 2008885