Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
Follow our Twitter feedHeavy Rain review coming 5pm GMT...
SIGN IN/JOIN UP
GamesForumsCheatsStore
Red Dead Redemption gets pre-order bonuses | BioShock has "many stories" to be told, says 2K | Big names sign up for E3 2010 | Resident Evil 5 Gold: Series favs return | FFXIII 360 bundle headed to US | Fallout New Vegas lets you "shape the world" | Aliens vs. Predator close combat video | Battlefield "a better online game" than Modern Warfare 2 | Third Naughty Bear trailer arrives(!) | Ghost Recon: Future Soldier trailer out | Assassin's Creed goes to Rome | LA Noir release window confirmed | Forza 3 Nurburgring Track DLC | FIFA fans break Guinness World Record | Xbox Live schedule: Resi 5, Katamari on Demand | MLB 2K10 gameplay trailer arrives | Halo: Reach Covenant is 'terrifying' | BioShock 2: More Avatar gear | 3D Project Natal has 'a lot of potential' | All EA titles "will have an online component" | BioShock 2 review round-up | BioShock 2 is "only pure shooter out right now" | Deus Ex: Human Revolution trademarked | Wada statement baffles FFXIII devs | Ghost Recon: Future Soldier breaks cover
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Download PC Games
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » Xbox » News
PreviousGJ09: MSN Multiplayer Game of the Year GJ09: PC GOTY isn't Left 4 Dead  Next

GJ09: Xbox Game Of The Year

What do you reckon, Gears or Halo?
Anyone who says that Xbox 360 is just for fans of shooters is bang on the money. Seriously. The final list of contenders reads like the who's who of the action genre. You've got Gears of War 2, Fallout 3, Call of Duty World at War, Fable II and Left 4 Dead. There's not even a racing game in there.

But because there was no Halo released during the period the Joysticks measures, the winner went to, yep Gears Of War 2.

Gears of War 2Official trailer
1:06  Combustible map pack
Click to playClick to play in HD
Now playingMore videosShare this 
Watch tons of other game videos in HD over on our video channel!

computerandvideogames.com
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
Read all 10 commentsPost a Comment
Good call, IMO. While I prefer the background setting of the "Halo" universe, I much prefer the actual gameplay of "GoW 2". Both "Halo 3" and "GoW 2" executed some rather superb voice acting, set pieces and storylines from where I'm standing.
The_KFD_Case on 30 Oct '09
I would've put Fable 2 and L4D ahead of Gears 2 for overall enjoyment, but all three are superb titles so it could've gone to any of them...a great year for 360 gaming in general!
Tonyb on 30 Oct '09
Yay! Great Game that really does deserved this award
J03Woo on 30 Oct '09
Am I the only Xbox owner who hates both GOW and Halo and find them both very boring and seem to be made with attention defficit teens in mind?!?

Personally I think Fallout 3 should of won it, but I spose it did get the overall game of the year Very Happy
Jokai on 30 Oct '09
Am I the only Xbox owner who hates both GOW and Halo and find them both very boring and seem to be made with attention defficit teens in mind?!?

Personally I think Fallout 3 should of won it, but I spose it did get the overall game of the year Very Happy

I reckon as 360 owners go, you're almost certainly in the bottom 1% who find/found Gears and Halo in anyway boring, let alone designed for ADHD "youths!"

Or maybe it's just that you're not cut out for "full on" action console games with superb on-line gameplay...Fallout 3 is a good game, but not even worthy of a mention in the same breath as Halo!
Tonyb on 30 Oct '09
I reckon as 360 owners go, you're almost certainly in the bottom 1% who find/found Gears and Halo in anyway boring, let alone designed for ADHD "youths!"

Or maybe it's just that you're not cut out for "full on" action console games with superb on-line gameplay...Fallout 3 is a good game, but not even worthy of a mention in the same breath as Halo!

Lol I like it, saying that Halo's online action is superb is pushing it a little Rolling Eyes

It reminds me too much of playing Quake or Unreal Tournament, was okay 7-8 years ago but I grew out of games which required bunny-hopping and has teenage yanks hurling racial/homophobic rants at you.

I know alot of people say Halo showed that consoles could do FPS games but personally I give that crown to Goldeneye Twisted Evil

Don't wanna start a flame war but Halo's online play is a step backwards.

Gimme BFBC or even MW over Halo anyday.

Just can't understand is popularity Embarassed

Although I will say a Halo or GOW movie would be pretty cool, just the games that suck Surprised
Jokai on 30 Oct '09
not sure gears should have won, but the 360 is geared towards shooter fans (im one!!), you only have to look and have a go with the controller, totally made for shooters, whilst the ps3 pad is absolute s**t for shooters....
headspin on 31 Oct '09
not sure gears should have won, but the 360 is geared towards shooter fans (im one!!), you only have to look and have a go with the controller, totally made for shooters, whilst the ps3 pad is absolute s**t for shooters....
Correction the PS3 pad is s**t for everything and i also hate gears of bore so your not alone Jokai!
dangermou5e on 31 Oct '09
I reckon as 360 owners go, you're almost certainly in the bottom 1% who find/found Gears and Halo in anyway boring, let alone designed for ADHD "youths!"

Or maybe it's just that you're not cut out for "full on" action console games with superb on-line gameplay...Fallout 3 is a good game, but not even worthy of a mention in the same breath as Halo!

Lol I like it, saying that Halo's online action is superb is pushing it a little Rolling Eyes

It reminds me too much of playing Quake or Unreal Tournament, was okay 7-8 years ago but I grew out of games which required bunny-hopping and has teenage yanks hurling racial/homophobic rants at you.

I know alot of people say Halo showed that consoles could do FPS games but personally I give that crown to Goldeneye Twisted Evil

Don't wanna start a flame war but Halo's online play is a step backwards.

Gimme BFBC or even MW over Halo anyday.

Just can't understand is popularity Embarassed

Although I will say a Halo or GOW movie would be pretty cool, just the games that suck Surprised

You pays your money and you takes your choice, I guess!

Battlefield and Modern Warfare bore the s**t out of me, the Halo series are head and shoulders more enjoyable than both Quake and Unreal combined, in fact both latter titles are massively over-rated!

As I mentioned previously, I think you are almost certainly in the minority of 360 owners regarding Halo and specifically Halo 3 which is still consistently in the top 3 games played on-line, so Bungie must have got something right, or should that be, everything right!... and Gears 2 isn't three bad either.
Tonyb on 31 Oct '09
It makes sense. If TLAD was released in '08, then that would have probably won.
The Bossman on 1 Nov '09
Read all 10 commentsPost a Comment
// Related Content
Reviews:
Previews:
Interviews:
News:
More Related
// The Best ofCVG
Click here to subscribe to OXM magazine.
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Tomb Raider: Underworld | Grand Theft Auto IV | Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare | Burnout Paradise | Halo 3 | Xbox 360 Elite
Bioshock | Rainbow Six: Vegas | BattleBlock Theatre | Vanquish | FIFA World Cup 2010
Top Reviews: BioShock 2 | BioShock 2 | Dante's Inferno | Assassin's Creed II: Battle of Forli | Mass Effect 2 | Dark Void
Lego Indiana Jones 2 | Assassins Creed 2 | Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 | Dragon Age: Origins | DJ Hero
Copyright 2006 - 2009 Future Publishing Limited,
Beauford Court, 30 Monmouth Street, Bath, UK BA1 2BW
England and Wales company registration number 2008885